FEMA’s Fakery Real — Dumb!
Monday, October 29th, 2007Once again FEMA is the laughing stock of the country. I’ve heard of people doing a lot of stupid things in dealing with the media, but FEMA’s latest bungle is almost beyond belief. They actually faked a news conference! The only good news — at least this time the agency’s ineptness didn’t risk people’s lives.
FEMA called a supposed news briefing to discuss the California fires 15 minutes before they went live. With so little warning, no reporters could physically make it to the location in time, but they were able to call in on an 800 number. With one catch — they could only listen to what was being said and couldn’t ask questions.
So, you wonder, who did do the asking?
FEMA staffers! That’s why the questions posed to Vice Admiral Harvey Johnson, the deputy administrator, included such stumpers as, “Are you happy with FEMA’s response so far?” Hmmm, let me think about that.
After the agency’s deceit was discovered, FEMA’s deputy director of public affairs, Mike Widomski, said they’d been mobbed with reporters’ phone calls, so they threw the briefing together at the last moment. He claimed the questions weren’t made up, but were things that real reporters had been asking.
Home Security Secretary Michael Chertoff said what all of us are probably thinking (but in a nicer way than most of us would phrase it), “I think it was one of the dumbest and most inappropriate things I’ve seen since I’ve been in government.”
So far only one person has suffered for the “error in judgment.” FEMA’s external affairs director, Pat Philbin, was supposed to take over as head of public relations for the director of national intelligence. Now he won’t.
But I hope he isn’t the only scapegoat. Why would Johnson go ahead with the “news conference” knowing it wasn’t really a news conference? Or why didn’t he announce at the beginning that no reporters were participating, but that he would answer some of the commonly asked questions and then schedule another newser later? Why didn’t FEMA postpone the event until some actual reporters could arrive? Why didn’t the agency arrange a way for reporters to ask questions by phone, or FAX or email their questions?
It’s difficult to believe that people in such high positions could be so clueless. But I guess when government’s involved, we shouldn’t put anything past them.


